worldaudience

Clinical Laboratory Investigation of Involvement of Systematic Mycosis in Outbreak of Sudden Death Syndrome in Broiler Chicken in Kathmandu Valley Nep

Clinical Laboratory Investigation of involvement of Systematic mycosis in Outbreak of Sudden Death Syndrome in Broiler Chicken in Kathmandu Valley Nepal

 

Dr.Kedar Karki , Central Veterinary Laboratory in Kathmandu Tripureshwor, Nepal

 Dr Esmeraldo M. Cabana, Veterinary Pathologist, Animal Health Laboratories, Diagnostic Services Branch Department of Primary Industries and Water, Tasmania, Australia,

 

 

ABSTRACT:

The incidence of sudden death of broiler birds above 40 days suddenly increased in the month of August 2008 in Kathmandu valley. Birds that were presented for post-mortem examination in Central Veterinary Laboratory Tripureswor Kathmandu were usually found dead on their backs with wings out-stretched. Incidence rate was recorded between 1.5 to 2.5% of the flock. The mean mortality due to sudden death syndrome was 1.3 – 9.6% and mortality usually occurs after 6 week of age. Postmortem examination of birds that died of sudden death syndrome revealed following major outstanding gross pathology. All birds were well fleshed, with muscle oedema and general pulmonary congestion and oedema. Feed was present along the entire digestive tract and the gall bladders of birds were usually filled with bile. The liver was pale to yellow enlarged molted appearance and kidneys were usually slightly congested and have patchy subcapsular haemorrhage. Usually, the proventriculus contains a milky fluid with hemorrhagic patches and intact food particles are present in gizzard. Crop in some bird was full with liquid intact food particles. Intestine was ballooning in appearance with thick mucous filled  ingesta was present .Congestive splenomegaly was observed in almost all birds. Bursa was almost normal to atrophid.

 

Penicillium spp., Aspergillus spp., Candida spp, E.coli, Streptococcus spp. and Staphylococcus spp. were the usual organisms isolated from culture samples of liver, lung, spleen and proventriculus. Reduction of mortality was achieved by feed restriction, supplementation of glucose containing electrolyte, liquid toxin binder, Immunomodulaters, acidifier and antibiotic therapy. The condition seems to be related to fast growth rate. A practical approach seems to use diets with 5-7% reduction in nutrient density. The provision of more space and supportive treatment with anti-stress medicine may also be beneficial.

 

 

 

Key word:

Sudden death syndrome , broiler birds, Kathmandu Valley, Nepal

 

 

 

Background of outbreak of Sudden Death Syndrome in Kathmandu Valley.

 

From the first week of August 2008 there sudden increase in mortality of broilers above 6 week age (Table 1). There are no premonitory signs. Just before death, birds appear normal and it is common to observe the birds feeding, drinking or walking normally. Then suddenly, affected birds exhibit clinical signs such as extending their neck, squawk and start wing beating as well as leg extension before falling back on their back and die suddenly.

 

 

 

 

Table: 1. Epidemiology of Affected flock in Kathmandu Valley with sudden Death Syndrome in Month of August 2008:

 

Duration

no.of farm

Population at risk

Morbidity

(%)

Mortality

(%)

No. of samples examined

 

First week

22

16620

4250 (25.57%)

369

(2.22%)

44

Second week

14

15450

1235

(7.99%)

232

(1.50%)

28

Third  week

20

10260

848

(8.26%)

157

(1.53%)

40

Fourth week

30

15700

2380

(15.16%)

149

(0.94%)

60

Fifth week

13

16450

4750

(30%)

1650

(0.3%)

26

Sixth week

12

18850

4550

(25%)

876

(0.19%)

24

Total

111

93330

18013

(17.01%)

3436 (1.56%)

222

 

Postmortem finding of SDS birds:

 

Postmortem examination of birds that died of sudden death syndrome revealed showed no outstanding gross pathology. All birds were well fleshed, with muscle oedema and general pulmonary congestion and oedema. Feed was present along the entire digestive tract and the gall bladders of birds were usually filled with bile. The liver was pale to yellow enlarged molted appearance and kidneys were usually slightly congested and have patchy subcapsular haemorrhage. Usually, the proventriculus contains a milky fluid with hemorrhagic patches and intact food particles are present in gizzard. Crop in some bird was full with liquid intact food particles. Intestine was ballooning in appearance with thick mucous filled  ingesta was present .Congestive splenomegaly was observed in almost all birds. Bursa was almost normal to atrophid.All these post mortem observations conform to the descriptions of the syndrom made by Ononiwu et. al. (1979).

 

 

Laboratory Finding of Mycobiota and Microbiota of Postmortem Tissue samples:

 

A total 86 tissue samples of lung, iver, speen, peoventriculus and gizzard, were collected during postmortem examination and were subjected for both bacterial and mycological culture. Results of microbiological examination done are given in Table 2.

 

 

 

Table: 2.

 

No. of samples

Bacterial isolated

Fungi isolated

Positive no

negative no

111

E.coli,

Streptococcus,

Staphylococcus

 

70

41

111

 

Aspergillus,

Penicillium,

Candida

80

31

222

 

 

150

72

 

Treatment and Preventive measure given to the rest of birds in flock:

 

All birds remaining in flocks were subjected to restricted feed up to 8-10%, and feed to twice daily only. Supplementation with glucose containing electrolyte, liquid toxin binders, immunomodulator, and simple broad-spectrum antibiotics were provided in water.Antibiotics like tylosin,inroxin,cholertin,anticoccicidal drugs and Vitamin B complex supplementation was totally withdrawn. All birds remaining in all affected farms responded well to the above management and there were marked improvement in the overall condition of the flock.

 

Discussion.

 

Sudden Death Syndrome (SDS) is an acute heart failure disease that affects mainly male fast growing chickens that seem to be in good condition. Although a common condition in fast growing birds, the pathogenesis remains unclear (Ononiwu et. al. 1979). Cardiac arrhythmias are involved in the pathogenesis of SDS with ventricular arrhythmias (VA) being the most common observation representing premature ventricular contractions and fibrillation (Olkowski and Classen, 1997; 1998). It has been reported that broilers fed with high vitamin D3 diet above the recommended levels in an attempt to prevent commonly occurring leg problems were 2.5 fold more likely to succumb to acute heart failure and die of SDS (Nain et. Al. 2007). SDS was also experimentally induced by feeding diets containing the mycotoxin moniliformin that resulted to cardiac injury with subsequent alterations in cardiac electrical conductance (Reams et al, 1997) suggesting the possible role of chronic mycotoxicosis to the causation of SDS. Due to the effect of chronic  mycosis Proventriculi lose their normal flusiform shape and normal constriction at the junction with gizzard are diffusely enlarged and have a thickened and turgidwall. Thickening of the wall is more marked upon incising the proventriculus.The proventricular glands protrude irregularly from the mucosal surface, lose their normal pattern and contain milky fluid that could be expressed with slight pressure. The gizzard is often smaller than normal and flabby. The gizzard peels off easily with haemorrhagic ulceration of the gizzard wall(Dr. Avinash Dhawale)   Other implicated causes of SDS include continuous artificial lighting (Ononiwu et al, 1979b), deviations in dietary calcium and phosphorus (Scheideler et al, 1995),  feeding crumble-pellet diets (Proudfoot et al, 1982), dietary fat content (Rotter et al, 1985) and feeding frequency Bowes et al, 1988). The latter recommendation of restricted feeding supports well the previous observation that abdominal fat deposition increases the risk of SDS such that restrictions on calorie:protein ratio decreases the incidence of SDS (Mollison et al, 1984). The SDS seems to be worse when biotin is marginal and other Vitamin B are in excess. Among many drugs used in poultry the role of anticoccidial drugs perhaps have received more attention than other drugs. There is some evidence of higher SDS mortality when anticoccidial drugs are used. (Dr.H.A.Upendra.www.vetcareindia.com/halchal_Sudden death Syndrome.htm 2008).

 

The present investigation indicates that broilers in good body weight condition when not harvested timely and remain in poultry shade for prolonged periods suffer stressful events and even sudden death. Also, it is possible that the increased humidity and hot season favors the growth of mold and fungus in stored feeds increasing the risk of birds to mycotoxicosis.This is indicated by the presence of feed and fluid filled crop,pale yellowish coloration of liver hepatomegaly and full distended gall bladder,milky fluid with hemorrhagic patches in muscular junction of gizzard and proventriculus yellowish tinge color of gizzard surface and intact feed in gizzard seems to be exaggerated the syndrome which has not been reported by any previous worker. This incidence of sudden death syndrome in birds in Kathmandu Valley was reported for the first time and needs to be investigated further.

 

 

Lyrics : I used to think that love was just a fairy tale Until that first hello until that first smile But if I had to do it all again I wouldn’t change a thing Cause this love is everlasting Suddenly life has new meaning to me There’s beauty up above and things we never take notice of You wake up suddenly you’re in love Girl you’re everthing a man could want and more One thousand words are not enough to say what I feel inside Holding hands as we walk along the shore Never felt like this before now you’re all I’m living for Each day I pray this love affair would last forever There’s beauty up above and things you never take notice of You wake and suddenly you’re in love
Video Rating: 4 / 5

More Suddenly Articles

Deer Hunting: Where it All Began

Deer hunting began years ago as a way for men to provide for their families. Over the years, a man’s stature began to be measured by how well he could hunt and provide food. In many Indian tribes, the elders were the best hunters or the group. As America was developed, this became a trait of the white civilization as well. Through the years, trophy deer hunting has moved past racial lines and the need to provide food for one’s family. However, if you spend one day in a hunting club, you will find stature is still measured by the biggest trophy or kill.

There is an understanding between hunters that the bigger the kill the better the hunter. While this is not always the case, it can sometimes be true that bigger is better. Trophy deer are measured by the number of points on their racks. Points are the knobs or ends or an antler rack. As a deer grows, its rack will also grow bigger to include more points and with age comes understanding. The more seasons a trophy deer has survived, the more likely they are to survive another. Just like any other animal, a deer will learn to adapt its routine to avoid hunters. Deer will learn what gun shots sound like and avoid any areas they hear them coming from.

These patterns of learning often lead to the local stories of the one big trophy buck that always gets away. While some towns may very well have one predominate buck that has been around a few years, there are stories of bucks living through generations. Some families will have a story of the one that escaped the dad, the son, and maybe even the grandfather. This is not a possible occurrence though, most deer live to be less than 15 years old and deer in a denser population will survive less than that.

When checking in a trophy dear, you will realize the excitement that goes along with it. Pictures will be taken with the dead animal. Strangers may even request a quick photo op. If your trophy deer is the biggest or first of the season, you are likely to find your picture in the paper in most small towns. In many small town papers, the deer hunting announcements can take up a whole page. Along with these pictures, go the bragging rights for the next year. That is until the next season.

To many hunters, bagging that famous buck is not always the goal. Many still hunt simply for the love of the sport. They simply enjoy the thrill of man verses beast. It is more about the hunt and the excitement than the actual kill. These hunters would rather spend a week in the infamous deer woods awaiting the kill, than get their kill on the first day and go back home. However, if you ask even these dedicated hunters, they would tell you getting the big trophy deer sure wouldn’t be a disappointment.

Voice Prompts and Voicemail Greetings by Professional Voice Talent Boosts Image

More and more businesses who use voicemail and voice prompts for their phone system including  pbx, auto attendant  and IVR system developers are realizing that their  telephone voicemail and voice prompt recordings play a large role in impressing customers and bolstering their image. Those businesses and voice prompt developers who want their company to reflect a professional image are utilizing professional voice talent such as Lecia Macryn Voice Services www.Macryn.com who specialize in recording custom voice prompts and voicemail greetings for all types of phone systems, cell phones, auto attendant, pbx systems, and IVR (Interactive Voice Response).

Professionally recorded voice greetings and prompts help clients feel they are associating with a stable, established company and make a positive impression.  Callers are more apt to place more confidence in a company or phone interaction where the phone presence is confident, clear and professional. 

Voice greetings and voice prompts can be sent via internet in any format or recorded into any phone, including mobile/cell phones.  Lecia Macryn Voice Services, www.Macryn.com  works with small and large businesses, ivr developers, customer satisfaction survey companies, auto attendant/pbx systems, and all types of telephony applications and projects.  Most recording requests can be delivered same day, if needed and a free sample audition is provided as well to ensure the voice recordings are what the client wants.

Lecia Macryn Voice Services has been providing recordings for clients worldwide since 1993 and can accommodate the small business owner who has just one basic voicemail recording …to the most extensive voice prompt application entailing thousands of recordings,

Demos and more information is available at: www.Macryn.com or call Lecia Macryn Voice Services at (248) 288-2242.

“the Voice” is sung by Lisa Kelly with Mairead Nesbitt on the violin. Celtic Women Official Site: www.celticwoman.com Spam & Rude Comments will be deleted!

Clinical Laboratory Outbreak of Sudden Death Syndrome in Broiler Chicken in Kathmandu Valley Nepal

Clinical Laboratory Outbreak of Sudden Death Syndrome in Broiler Chicken in Kathmandu Valley Nepal

 

 

1: Dr.Kedar Karki Senior Veterinary Officer

Central Veterinary Laboratory in Kathmandu Tripureshwor, Nepal

 

2: Dr Esmeraldo M. Cabana, Veterinary Pathologist,

 Animal Health Laboratories, Diagnostic Services Branch Department of Primary Industries and Water, Tasmania, Australia,

ABSTRACT:

The incidence of sudden death of broiler birds above 40 days suddenly increased in the month of August 2008 in Kathmandu valley. Birds that were presented for post-mortem examination in Central Veterinary Laboratory Tripureshwor Kathmandu were usually found dead on their backs with wings out-stretched. Incidence rate was recorded between 1.5 to 2.5% of the flock. The mean mortality due to sudden death syndrome was 1.3 – 9.6% and mortality usually occurs after 6 week of age. There are no outstanding gross lesions on post mortem examinations, except for muscle oedema, pulmonary, renal and liver congestion, and congestive spleenomegally.

 

Penicillium spp., Aspergillus spp., Candida spp, E.coli, Streptococcus spp. and Staphylococcus spp. were the usual organisms isolated from culture samples of liver, lung, spleen and proventriculus. Reduction of mortality was achieved by feed restriction, supplementation of glucose containing electrolyte, liquid toxin binder, Immunomodulater, acidifier and antibiotic therapy. The condition seems to be related to fast growth rate. A practical approach seems to use diets with 5-7% reduction in nutrient density. The provision of more space and supportive treatment with anti-stress medicine may also be beneficial.

 

Key word:

Sudden death syndrome, broiler birds, Kathmandu Valley, Nepal

 

 

 

Background of outbreak of Sudden Death Syndrome in Kathmandu Valley.

 

During the first week of August 2008 there sudden increase in mortality of broilers above 6 week age (Table 1). There are no premonitory signs. Just before death, birds appear normal and it is common to observe the birds feeding, drinking or walking normally. Then suddenly, affected birds exhibit clinical signs such as extending their neck, squawk and start wing beating as well as leg extension before falling back on their back and die suddenly.

 

Table: 1. Epidemiology of Affected flock with sudden Death Syndrome in Month of August 2008:

 

Duration

no. of farm

Population at risk

Morbidity

(%)

Mortality

(%)

No. of samples examined

 

First week

22

16620

4250 (25.57%)

369

(2.22%)

44

Second week

14

15450

1235

(7.99%)

232

(1.50%)

28

Third  week

20

10260

848

(8.26%)

157

(1.53%)

40

Fourth week

30

15700

2380

(15.16%)

149

(0.94%)

60

Total

86

58030

8713

(15.01%)

907

(1.56%)

172

 

Postmortem finding of SDS birds:

 

Postmortem examination of birds that died of sudden death syndrome revealed showed no outstanding gross pathology. All birds were well fleshed, with muscle edema and general pulmonary congestion and edema. Feed was present along the entire digestive tract and the gall bladders of birds are usually empty. The liver and kidneys were usually slightly congested and have patchy sub capsular hemorrhage. Usually, the proventriculus contains a milky fluid, and intact food particles are present in gizzard. Congestive spleenomegally was observed in almost all birds. All these post mortem observations conform to the descriptions of the syndrome made by Ononiwu et. al. (1979).

 

 

Laboratory Finding of Mycobiota and Micro biota of Postmortem Tissue samples:

 

A total 86 tissue samples of lung, liver, spleen, Proventriculus and gizzard, were collected during postmortem examination and were subjected for both bacterial and mycological culture. Results of microbiological examination done are given in Table 2.

 

Table: 2.

 

No. of samples

Bacterial isolated

Fungi isolated

Positive no

negative no

86

E.coli,

Streptococcus,

Staphylococcus

 

59

27

86

 

Aspergillus,

Penicillium,

Candida

58

28

172

 

 

117

55

 

Treatment and Preventive measure given to the rest of birds in flock:

 

All birds remaining in flocks were subjected to restricted feed up to 8-10%, and feed to twice daily only. Supplementation with glucose containing electrolyte, liquid toxin binders, Immunomodulater, and simple broad-spectrum antibiotics were provided in water. Vitamin B complex supplementation was totally withdrawn. All birds remaining in all affected farms responded well to the above management and there were marked improvement in the overall condition of the flock.

 

Result and Discussion.

 

Sudden Death Syndrome (SDS) is an acute heart failure disease that affects mainly male fast growing chickens that seem to be in good condition. Although a common condition in fast growing birds, the pathogenesis remains unclear (Ononiwu et. al. 1979). Cardiac arrhythmias are involved in the pathogenesis of SDS with ventricular arrhythmias (VA) being the most common observation representing premature ventricular contractions and fibrillation (Olkowski and Classen, 1997; 1998). It has been reported that broilers fed with high vitamin D3 diet above the recommended levels in an attempt to prevent commonly occurring leg problems were 2.5 fold more likely to succumb to acute heart failure and die of SDS (Nain et. Al. 2007). SDS was also experimentally induced by feeding diets containing the mycotoxin moniliformin that resulted to cardiac injury with subsequent alterations in cardiac electrical conductance (Reams et al, 1997) suggesting the possible role of chronic mycotoxicosis to the causation of SDS. Other implicated causes of SDS include continuous artificial lighting (Ononiwu et al, 1979b), deviations in dietary calcium and phosphorus (Scheideler et al, 1995),  feeding crumble-pellet diets (Proudfoot et al, 1982), dietary fat content (Rotter et al, 1985) and feeding frequency Bowes et al, 1988). The latter recommendation of restricted feeding supports well the previous observation that abdominal fat deposition increases the risk of SDS such that restrictions on calorie:protein ratio decreases the incidence of SDS (Mollison et al, 1984).

 

The present investigation indicates that broilers in good body weight condition when not harvested timely and remain in poultry shade for prolonged periods suffer stressful events and even sudden death. Also, it is possible that the increased humidity and hot season favors the growth of mold and fungus in stored feeds increasing the risk of birds to mycotoxicosis. This incidence of sudden death syndrome in birds in Kathmandu Valley was reported for the first time and needs to be investigated further.

 

References.

 

Bowes VA, R.J. Julian, S. Leeson and T. Stirtzinger (1988). Effect of feed restriction on feed efficiency and incidence of sudden death syndrome in broiler chickens. Poultry Science 67(7):1102-4

 

Mollison B., W. Guenter,and B.R. Boycott (1984). Abdominal fat deposition and sudden death syndrome in broilers: the effects of restricted intake, early life caloric (fat) restriction, and calorie: protein ratio. Poultry Science 63(6):1190-200

 

Nain S, B. Laarveld B, C. Wojnarowicz C, and A.A. Olkowski (2007). Excessive dietary vitamin D supplementation as a risk factor for sudden death syndrome in fast growing commercial broilers. Comparative biochemistry and physiology. Part A, Molecular & Integrative Physiology 148(4):828-33

 

Olkowski, A.A., C. Wojnarowicz, S. Nain, B. Ling, J. M. Alcorn, and B. Laarveld (2008). A study on pathogenesis of sudden death syndrome in broiler chickens. Research in Veterinary Science 2008 Aug;85(1):131-40

 

Ononiwu, J.C., R.G. Thomson, H.C. Carlson, and R.J. Julian. (1979). Pathological Studies of “Sudden Death Syndrome” in Broiler Chickens. Canadian Veterinary Journal 20(3): 70–73

 

Ononiwu, J.C., R.G. Thomson, H.C. Carlson, and R.J. Julian. (1979b). Studies on effect of lighting on “Sudden death syndrome” in broiler chickens. . Canadian Veterinary Journal 20(3):74-7

 

Olkowski A.A. and H.L. Classen (1998). High incidence of cardiac arrhythmias in broiler chickens. Zentralblatt für Veterinärmedizin. Reihe A 45(2):83-91

 

Olkowski A.A. and H.L. Classen (1997). Malignant ventricular dysrhythmia in broiler chickens dying of sudden death syndrome. Veterinary Record. 15;140(7):177-9

 

Proudfoot FG, H.W. Hulan, K.B. McRae (1982). The effect of crumbled and pelleted feed on the incidence of sudden death syndrome among male chicken broilers. Poultry Science 61(8):1766-8

 

Reams R.Y, H.L. Thacker, D.D. Harrington, M.N. Novilla, G.E. Rottinghaus, G.A. Bennett , and J. Horn (1997). A sudden death syndrome induced in poults and chicks fed diets containing Fusarium fujikuroi with known concentrations of moniliformin. Avian Disease 41(1):20-35

 

Rotter B, W. Guenter, and B.R. Boycott (1985). Sudden death syndrome in broilers: dietary fat supplementation and its effect on tissue composition. Poultry Science 64(6):1128-36

Scheideler SE, D.V. Rives, J.D. Garlich, and P.R. Ferket (1995). Dietary calcium and phosphorus effects on broiler performance and the incidence of sudden death syndrome mortality. Poultry Science 74(12):2011-8

 

 

Acknowledgment:

 

We would like to thank Dr. Dev Raj Adhikari SVO and incharge of Central Veterinary Hospital Tripureshwor, Kathmandu for providining early indication of problem. Thanks are due to Dr.Pragya Koirala Veterinary Officer Mr.Bal Bahadur Kunwar Srnior Vet.Technician and Mr.Bhimsen Adhikari Vet.Technician of Microbioly Unit of Central Veterinary Laboratory for doing the microbiology works, Dr. Lin Tsang Long, Avian Pathologist, and Dr. Stephen B. Hooser, Stephen, Head, Toxicology Section and Assistant Director, Animal Disease Diagnostic Laboratory Purdue University U.S.A for their critique of the manuscript. Dr.Poornima Manandhar, Chief of CVL Tripureshwor deserves special thanks from this investigation team.

 

Olivia Newton-John & Cliff Richard — SUDDENLY

Related Suddenly Articles

Wild Oregano Oil is 100% organic certified with 80% carvacol

Research supports the use of Wild Oregano oil against viral and fungal infections and it destroys many strains of bacteria and other parasites. Studies conducted by Georgetown University in Washington, D.C., have shown that the wild, mountain-grown oregano is an excellent anti-fungal agent, completely killing Candida albicans.

 

Origaum Vulgare or Wild Oregano is a native Mediterranean woody shrub of Europe. A herb rich in carvacol –The most potent natural antiseptic with miraculous antibiotic properties. Carvacol is the strongest laboratory tested antiseptic known to mankind till date.

 

The Oil of Wild Oregano is an age old potent health aid, a panacea for all pathogenic infections. Tiny amounts of this wild oil helps you in quickly protecting yourself and your family against various pathogens such as bacteria, virus, fungus, yeast and other parasites. It is nature’s “natural antiseptic.” Up until 1950, it was used to sterilize operating instruments.

 

Through ages Oregano oil has been used against various ailments such as Cold, Flu, Cough , Sore Throat , Sinusitis, Bronchitis, Bladder and Kidney Infections , Indigestion, Stomach infections,  Diarrhea, Peptic Ulcer, tumors, Allergies, Infections of the sex organs, chest infections, Liver disorders, Bad Breath, Gums infection and many more. It is very effective against Parasites such as Cryptosporidium, Staphylococcus aureas, Escherichia coli, Yersinia enterocolitica, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and others.

 

History tells us that Gerard, the 17th century British herbalist, described the oil of oregano as a remedy for digestive complaints and head colds. William Langham, in Garden of Health (1633), described a wide range of uses in diverse conditions such as bladder trouble, bleeding, heart failure, head pain, itchy skin, mouth pain, freckles or spots on the skin, stomachache, intestinal worms, and toothache. . In the 15th century, Paracelsus used Wild Oregano to treat diarrhea, psoriasis, vomiting, jaundice, and fungal diseases.

 

Oil of Wild Oregano is rich in natural carvacol –nature’s strongest antimicrobial. It is an age old remedy against infections for all sorts of pathogens such as bacteria, virus, fungus, yeast and other parasites. Its usage has no side effects and builds your immunity besides fighting against antibodies.

 

Advantages:

It protects you and your family against varied pathogens on a diverse platform. It’s your quick doctor at home easily available.

 

It has no side effects, thus protecting you against potential drug side effects and also mutant variations.

 

It builds your internal immunity making you internally strong to fight against pathogens.

 

And pathogens are not able to build immunity against Wild Oregano Oil as with the pharmaceutical drugs.

 

Suggested Use:

 

Nature Supplies Natural Wild Oregano Oil is 100% organic certified with 80% carvacol.

It is mixed with extra virgin olive oil 3:1 for greater health benefit as this specific concentration gets faster absorption into the blood stream both externally and internally.

 

A skin sensitivity test is highly recommended before external use.

 

Take 1-3 drops of the oil, rub vigorously over the affected area such as bladder region or stomach in case of pain or discomfort. Repeat 3 times a day for a period of 1-2 weeks.

 

Wild Oregano Oil consumed internally too as well as can be rubbed on gums as an anti-inflammatory.

 

‘Nature Supplies’ provides 100% organic, 80% carvacol rich wild oregano oil in the most convenient dropper bottles.

Better Trades – a Better Teaching Strategy

Do you really want to learn your stock market trading strategies from someone who has never traded?

One of the problems of the Internet is that there are hundreds of people and countless websites that say they know how to use the stock market when they are simply regurgitating the information available everywhere. If you’re trying to build your personal wealth, reading the same information found on virtually every trading website simply won’t help. Fortunately, there’s a better way.

BetterTrades is a truly unique educational company in the world of trading. We rely on live events that you attend in person to ensure that you are learning trading information unavailable anywhere else. Interactive seminars, live mentoring, online courses and specialized trading information are also used to help you get a maximum return. Our interactive multi-training makes BetterTrades an exceptional resource for any trader either new or experienced.

One of the best things about Better Trades is that all of the instructors are experienced traders who have worked extensively with the stock market in the past. With over 200 years of combined experience, you’ll find a team that has written a multitude of books and designed thousands of seminars. You’ll also find the only team who can help you meet your personal wealth goals.

Many of the instructors began their stock market experience with virtually no training. For some, trading was a hobby. As they realized that they were able to fulfill their own financial goals, trading became much more. Because our instructors began their trading career as novices, you’ll get realistic advice that teaches you the necessary skills to get started. Free of the technical jargon that can confuse many beginners, you’ll learn how to make a fortune no matter what the market conditions.

With thousands of satisfied students to date, BetterTrades is an educational company that provides personalized advice. With highly educational classes that will teach you to apply smart trading tactics, you could turn a few hundred dollars into thousands in just a few months. If you’re not trading as successfully as you like, it’s time to contact BetterTrades.

Better Trades is for those who truly want to learn how to trade in the stock market. After all, why would you use another company whose instructors have never traded when you can work with a faculty that has made its own personal fortune from the techniques offered in each class? Contact BetterTrades today, and start your trading education.

This article is originally published here: Better Trades

 

Ugg Classic Tall: The Timeless Footwear For Comfort and Style

Fashion for women does not only mean wearing stilettos as well as sexy and classy clothes, it could also mean a pair of Ugg Classic Tall boots worn over a pair of jeans or her favorite mini skirt. Yes, boots can be fashionable too especially if they come from UGG Australia and is made with the softest sheepskin and wool possible. Because what exactly is fashion if you cannot be comfortable wearing them?

The Evolution of the Ugg Classic Tall Boots

If you want to own a pair of footwear that is timeless when it comes to what they can provide for you, then the Ugg Classic Tall is definitely the one you are looking for. Originally made to be worn by shepherds in Australia so that their feet can be kept warm at all times, the ugg boots were then discovered by pilots who flew at high altitudes during World War II. After the pilots, the use of the ugg boots was then taken over by the surfers who wore them after their chilly adventures in the ocean. Now, these fur-lined boots that feature flat soles are being worn by celebrities and supermodels making appearances not only in streets but also in catwalks, tabloids, and even shows in television as well.

There are now a great number of women who just can’t live without their ugg boots, especially the Ugg Classic Tall. Although this could probably be because these boots were seen to have shod the feet of such women as Kate Moss, Cameron Diaz and Sarah Jessica Parker, this could also be definitely because they are not only fashionable but warm, soft, and comfortable as well. As they are made with only the best sheepskin and wool materials, you are assured that the Ugg Classic Tall boots will also let your feet breathe, thus making it possible for you to wear them even during hot seasons.

The Functionality of the Ugg Classic Tall Boots

Now, if you think that comfort and fashion is all there is to the timeless Ugg Classic Tall boots, you have to think again. The functionality of these boots can’t be equaled as well. Because of their comfort and design, you can easily wear your Ugg Classic Tall boots with a pair of jeans and shirt. Whether you wear them under or over your jeans, it does not even matter, you are still guaranteed to look great in them and feel more comfortable too. If you are wearing a miniskirt or a knit dress or even a pair of shorts to go out with your friends, you don’t have to suffer and wear your stilettos, you can just wear your Uggs. As there seems to be nothing that you can’t wear your pair of Ugg Classic Tall boots with, except for formal clothes, then you can wear this every day and wherever you go. Because they are also durable, then you are guaranteed to have them for a very long time with the proper care and maintenance. This makes your pair of Ugg Classic Tall the most timeless and functional footwear that you can ever own.

So if you must buy a pair of boots, don’t settle for anything less. Get yourself a pair of Ugg Classic Tall and experience the luxurious and timeless appeal that they can give you.

Eulogy Examples for Father – How to Use Examples to Write the Ultimate Father Eulogy

It is never easy to write about someone who has just passed away, especially if that person is your father. Your father is an important figure to you and writing about his life will undoubtedly feel like a very difficult task. On the other hand, writing your father’s eulogy can be a fairly simple and uncomplicated job to finish, especially if a eulogy example for a father is available to guide you.

You will be writing a piece that celebrates and commemorates your father’s life and a professionally-written eulogy example for a father can be of great help. A eulogy example for a father can be a very helpful tool when you begin writing, especially if you are clueless as to how to start. Reading a good example of a eulogy for a father will give you an idea as to what topics and points to include in your own eulogy.

A eulogy example for a father can certainly guide you in constructing your piece and will help you in determining what to include in your eulogy. You can get ideas on what kinds of things you can mention or say about your father, the flow of your speech, the tone your eulogy will take on, and much more. Professionally-written eulogies will show you how to bring your ideas together into one properly-ordered, cohesive speech. Most examples also take on a lighter and more uplifting note; you can take from this and likewise use a lighthearted tone in your eulogy. The passing away of loved ones is already a mournful experience, so an easy air about your eulogy will truly help.

When taking ideas from a professionally-written eulogy example for a father, be sure to avoid directly lifting the ideas from your sample. Instead, turn them into your own by rephrasing them and putting your own personal spin on your speech. Be careful that it doesn’t sound impersonal and cold, which is likely to occur if you copy an example verbatim. Remember that a eulogy example for a father is there to be your guide and not to serve as the eulogy itself.

Taking a good look at a eulogy example for a father can be a truly great help. By referring to one, it will be easy to construct your eulogy for your father. Eulogies are the perfect chance to take the sad air of mourning away for a bit and celebrate the life of an individual.

Pre-order Example’s new single ‘Kickstarts’ on iTunes bit.ly Buy Example – Won’t Go Quietly on iTunes: bit.ly Example – Won’t Go Quietly facebook.com/leadingbyexample twitter.com/exampleyoutwit I needed more than just a kiss goodnight Had to go get something out my system – I Ignored the warnings, bit the fruit, she might have tasted good But man she was my kryptonite Shoulda known she was trouble from the start – I Knew she’d broken hearts – I Thought I take that chance, dance – With the she-devil in the pale moon light Alarm bells rang but I loved the drama In a dark place but I loved the kharma – Sutra, shoulda closed that door But I kept going back for more Shes electric, Shes the current running through my veins Shes a siren, hearing voices that I cant explain Now I, Should be thinking it over Instead Im calling her over Now shes here and she wont go quietly Should be thinking it over Instead Im calling her over Now shes here and she wont go quietly I needed more than just a cheap thrill ride See I needed something that ran deep inside Ignored the warnings, bit the fruit, she might have tasted good But man she was my kryptonite Knew it wouldn’t last for a year – I, Knew it all end in tears – I Cracked – She was mad addictive, Never felt scripted, unpredictable Tied up but no strings attached Left scratch marks on my back Her cold eyes got me excited And I cant hide the truth Shes electric, Shes the current running through my veins (I just cant kick the habit, kick …
Video Rating: 4 / 5

Infinite Possibilities Positive Choices

“You and I are essentially infinite choice makers. In every moment of our existence we are in that field of all possibilities where we have access to an infinity of choices.” ~ Deepak Chopra

I believe that we are spirit travelling incognito as humans; in fact, I wrote a movie about that. The key concept to us, as spirit, is that we are swimming in infinite possibilities on a daily basis (not that time has the same meaning to spirit), and we have to make choices in order to “tangible-ize” our possibilities. Every day, we choose little things, whether to work out, what to eat, who to spend time with and what to work on throughout the day, and big things, like our interpretation of the meaning of life and how we want to show up in the world.

Our job is not necessarily to create opportunities but to decide which ones to pursue. And the hardest part about it is that there are no guarantees – there are only choices.

So how do we know what choices are best for us? A positive choice just feels good. Some part of us knows that it is the right thing to do. It opens up our lives and creates new momentum for the best of us to shine and be recognized, even if only by our own inner fan club. And we know when it’s time to make a new choice when we feel: stuck, tired, sick, confused, negative, fearful, bored, safe, comfortable… and more. We know when it’s time to make a new choice. The question really becomes: are we ready to have something new?

A positive choice moves us forward in some sense (even if it’s hard to do or against the well-intentioned advice of others) because it helps us become more aligned with our true purpose. It’s a choice that is about us, not about anybody else or their wishes or what they can gain by it – it’s truly in our best interest and we have the domain to make the choice at hand. A positive choice sets us up to win – we will gain something, whether it be knowledge, skills or experience, by pushing our growing edge.

3 Things You Can Do:

1. Look at where your growing edge is hiding. Consider where you are too comfy, or anxious, stuck, bored, fearful, negative… any feeling that isn’t absolutely free and flowing is a place where your growing edge for new choices is revealing itself.

2. Look at the results you’ve gotten / are getting. If don’t like the results of your life, which is shown through everything around you, it’s time to be accountable to yourself in a new way. New choices will require you to show up more clearly, in a more focused and powerful way. And how you show up by making new choices will generate new results – it is simple cause and effect. Change the cause (choice), and you change the effect (result).

3. Make a list of all your possibilities. Consider new directions you could be pursuing in the following areas: career/vocation, self-knowledge, family, wealth, reputation, marriage/relationships, communications, creativity, community, health. These possibilities might come from ideas, inspiration, new associations, doing something you’ve been putting off, advice from other people, enjoying a wish list thing… it’s pretty much endless. If you can list at least 3 new directions in these areas off the top of your head, you’ve got some choices to make – or you have to answer to yourself why you’re not decided to make new choices after making that list!

May you enjoy both the swim in infinite possibilities and the results from making positive choices!

More Is It Possible?: go.discovery.com Is It Possible to roller-skate down a rollercoaster and survive?

Knowledge As Emerging Patterns Of Interaction

Normal 0 Knowledge as emerging patterns

of interaction

Knowledge as Emerging Patterns of Interaction

1 Introduction

This paper examines how knowledge can be seen as continuously emerging patterns of interactions between individuals. It particularly focuses the nature of human organisations and how that nature affects the learning in individuals and -as a consequence- the continuous emergence of organisational knowledge. In order to do this, we will first look at the nature of organisations. This by examining what we see is the most helpful way to characterise organisations, clearly offsetting organisations as ‘systems’ versus ‘processes’. It will be clarified that knowledge may exist only in the interaction between people and can therefore not simply be reified as ‘tangible’, ‘tacit’ or ‘explicit’. We propose it exists in context and only in context. Thus, we consider knowledge as intrinsically social. Also, we consider knowledge as something that emerges only ‘from within’. There are no outsiders. Someone with information that exists in total isolation without the possibility to act cannot generate knowledge. This makes knowledge inherently ‘local’. ‘Global knowledge’, as in ‘best practices’ or ‘business processes’ are an illusion if they do not resonate with the experience of people in local interactions. We will use recent insights from the complexity sciences to examine the interactions and hence the continuous emergence of knowledge. It will become clear that ‘knowledge’ and ‘organising’ are ‘complicitly’ linked.

In the quote above from the ‘Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy’, this is illustrated with the illustrated with an interesting philosophical undertone, despite its inherent humour. The supercomputer Deep Tought took seven and a half million years to some up with the answer to Life, The Universe and Everything as the world-famous ‘42′. In the next chapter from the book the immediate implication is that we then first (sic!) have to know the ‘Ultimate Question’ (Adams, 1995: 128). It then is decided to build the Earth as the next generation supercomputer to find that Ultimate Question. Later in the book it becomes clear that the Ultimate Question is ‘six by nine’ (Adams, 1995: 305). At least, in base thirteen. All is contextual, you see.

2 Are organisations systems or processes?

The complexity sciences have emerged mainly from the natural sciences like physics, chemistry and biology. It has shown tremendous power in helping these sciences forward and explaining complex phenomena that previously could not be described adequately. These were those situations where the sheer number of interactions between particles or smaller units (the ‘local’) led to unpredictable behaviour on a global level. The complexity sciences were able to convincingly explain why simple global patterns emerge out of complex local interactions. Because of these successes, and the many complex issues that human organisations, and particularly business organisations, face complexity theory has often been used successfully as a metaphor to help organisations forward (see for instance Zimmerman, Lindberg & Plsek, 1998: 4-18). Understandably. Human organisations consist of many ‘agents’ interacting and display very complex and unpredictable behaviour. So much is not disputed. In order to be able to describe many of the observed behaviour people resorted to complexity theory. In natural systems, a very useful idea has been the definition of these bounded systems as ‘complex adaptive systems’ or CAS. The theory being that because of the complex interactions the system is ‘coupled’ to the external environment (perhaps via semi-permeable boundaries) so that they ‘adapt’ to it. Thus viewed, each system is ‘nested’ in a larger (‘higher’) system. Therefore it is a small step to then see human organisations as systems and consequently as complex adaptive systems, in parallel with the natural sciences. This view then logically leads to teams, departments, organisations, etc., being seen as ‘nested systems’ (Kelly & Allison, 1999: 12-13, 19). The next step is to realise that human organisations may not simply ‘adapt’ to the environment. Perhaps what they do is co-evolve in that environment. We may see them as Complex Evolving Systems, or CES. (See for instance Heylighen, 1997).

These metaphors are powerful ways to look at human organisations. The principles of self-organisations, emergence, ‘edge of chaos’, etc., from the complexity sciences can provide interesting new insights in issues that organisations face. Given the constant struggle in business organisations to find ways to ‘cope’ with the inherent uncertainty they face, these relatively new theories help to make sense. But, as with all metaphors, there is a risk that we take them too far. People started to have conversations on whether or not organisations are a CAS or CES. Then, by inference, we start to say that organisations therefore must comply with this and that observation for a CAS. An interesting example, for instance, is the debate between organizational professionals whether or not ‘therefore’ (sic!) ‘human systems’ emerge from ‘simple rules’. This, in turn, is inferred from simple computer based systems in which ‘boids’, having been programmed with three ‘simple rules’ start displaying behaviour that has been characterised as ‘flocking’, very much like a 2D projection of flocks of birds. But please note that in reality, these boids are just computer blips on a screen. The ‘simple rules’ can adequately describe the behaviour of those ‘blips’ on the screen. But that is all they can do! They cannot describe any real life flocking behaviour at all. Let alone describe how birds reproduce or multiply. Hardly a rich description of something as complex as a

living creature. But, since the observed ‘flocks’ were so convincing, it has been assumed most complex systems are somehow emerging from simple rules. Since a CAS can emerge from simple rules, so must human organisations, so people claim. That is why some people with some (but no more) notion of complexity theory state that what we have to do is ‘just find the simple rules’. These often are typified as ‘values’. Stating the simple rules than becomes ‘defining the values’ of the organisation. This is reverse logic. An Organisation is not a CAS. It may be modelled as a CAS, and as a metaphor that can give really powerful insights. But what are organisations, really? It may be helpful to start by what we know ‘for sure’ about human organisations. They consist of people interacting in their daily (working) practices. Therefore for the purpose of this paper we will start with that: the interaction between people in organisation that we will call ‘the social’. My claim in this paper is that a metaphor different from a ‘system’ may be more helpful to describe (the evolution of) organisational knowledge. The recent thinking from Ralph Stacey on complex responsive processes sees organisations not as systems, but rather chooses to pay attention to the interaction between people (Stacey, 2000). This view emphasises that organisations are not systems as such but looks as them as processes of people interacting. For the purpose of this paper I see this as a very helpful approach. These processes consist of ‘the narrative-like sequences of gesture and response between human bodies’ (Stacey, 2000: 146-148). In these interactions people continuously reinterpret their own experiences (‘past’) in order to act (‘gesture’) to achieve some future expected state. This expectation, in turn, feeds back on the interpretation of the past experiences. Each gesture triggers a similar process in other people who then ‘respond’ with a new gesture. With many interactions this is a highly complex process (hence the term ‘complex responsive processes of relating’).

With continued interaction, as is happening in organisations some ‘themes’ will

emerge. These themes emerge because of some common intention of the

future, real and existing differences in experience and intentions and real and

existing issues that exist in order to achieve this desired future. This

emergence is self-organising in nature. This is where insights from complexity

theory are very helpful indeed.

For the purpose of this paper I will call this process of emerging themes

‘patterning’ of the interaction between people.

There are a few implications that are paramount in this process.

For one, we need to realise that not all participants of this process are equally

‘autonomous’. Crucial, as pointed out also by Stacey c.s. (Stacey, 2000: 213-4),

are the power relations that exist in all interactions. ‘Some people are more

autonomous than others’.

Secondly, all action is action that is interpreted by each individual differently.

There is no ‘knowable truth’ other than what resonates with each individual’s

past experiences (sic!) and their individual intentions (sic!). Since all individual

past experiences as well as their individual intentions are different, so is each

individual’s ‘truth’.

Also, importantly, there is no guarantee that people will speak ‘the truth’. All

people will ‘gesture’ as to achieve their own desired future. In many

organisations not open and honestly sharing information is the norm rather

than the exception. Often, this is due to expected repercussions if the truth be

spoken. This means that conversations, as we can observe in all organisations,

are in fact the continuous negotiation of each person’s ‘intention’ and

‘expectations’. Thus, other people’s intentions become ‘enabling constraints’

(Stacey, 2000: 151-3) for these negotiations.

Richard Knowles (2002) has developed structured ways to examine the

processes of interaction and the emergent patterns. The combination of

Stacey’s complex responsive processes theory with Knowles’ self-organising

leadership theories could form a sound basis for studying knowledge

processes.

3 What is knowledge?

This is a paper about knowledge processes in organisations. We looked at

organisations as processes above.

I would like to use a definition from Dee Hock (1999), emeritus-CEO of VISA for

‘knowledge’ and the hierarchy he puts in it.

Noise

Data

Information

Knowledge

Understanding

Wisdom

Noise is the undifferentiated stuff happening all around us;

Data is the first level of organisation of the noise. It can be discerned and

differentiated by the human mind

Information is the next level of organisation of the data. Patterns and

relationships are starting to add meaning (Bateson’s ‘difference that

makes a difference’)

Knowledge is the organisation of the information in a way that in the

right context it becomes useful to act, decide or create new knowledge.

Understanding is organisation of knowledge by individuals in a manner

useful for conceiving, anticipating, evaluating and judging. This is a

unique, personal experience.

Wisdom is achieved when the understanding is informed by intention,

ethics, principle, memory of the past and projection into the future.

Science, including organisational science, has traditionally focused on data,

information and knowledge and has largely ignored Understanding and

Wisdom. In the context of this paper I would like to maintain that Knowledge

without Understanding is not useful for the sustainability of organisations. In

the context of complex responsive processes a deep understanding, as wisdom

in the above definitions, is paramount.

For long term survival and health of organisations knowledge processes should

recognise the need for understanding and wisdom.

This is an important statement.

If we analyse it a few things jump out:

Information as such is not knowledge; just having information is not

enough. ‘Just a book’ is not enough. That is ‘just’ information;

Knowledge is where pieces of information have been integrated;

knowledge, in that sense, has the potential to be novel. It also says that

more that one piece of information is required. This means at least a

form of diversity;

This combination has to happen in ‘the right context’. So, without the

combination happening the real world (context) there is no knowledge

just pieces of information;

This knowledge must be applied. Crucial. If we cannot use the combined

pieces of information to act it is -by definition- useless;

This knowledge in itself can then act as a new piece of information to

create new knowledge. This is the ‘recursiveness’ in this definition.

Understanding happens when individuals are able to project and apply

Seeing the importance of understanding, thus paying attention to

intention, ethics and principles, will lead to ‘organisational wisdom’ that

is seated in the individuals!

Thus phrased, ‘knowledge’ is continuously emerging where the context

requires the combination of pieces of available information in order to ‘act’.

In this definition knowledge is not something tangible. It can not be codified or

taken away. Information can. We can store information in databases. Knowledge

has to be contextual. Since the context exists only where and when people

apply the knowledge it can not be codified.

So, books or papers or databases are ways of codifying information. By reading

we start ‘contextualising’ this information in our heads. In this process we start

to create our own interpretation of this information. This interpretation is

dependent on our own personal past experiences and our own individual

expectations of the future. It either ‘resonates’ with our experience or it does

not. The information distilled from a book or paper or any other source will -by

default- always be different for the reader than from the writer. Meaning, thus,

is being created by the ‘responder’ not by the ‘gesturer’.

Reading it a second time around will again give different interpretations and -

hence- different pieces of information. Even the writer will interpret his/her own

writings differently a next time round.

This has as an implication that each piece of information will, by default,

already have in it a level of diversity if more than one person at any one time is

interacting round this piece of information. Stacey (2000: 202-6) quite

convincingly points out that it is this very diversity that makes that ‘novelty’ can

emerge out of the interactions. Without it, no novelty can occur. Put in a more

lyrical way, some one on his/her own in some remote and isolated desert can

acquire a massive amount of information (from books, etc.), without interaction

(diversity) true novelty will not occur.

If people interact they do that in a certain context. They will ‘be’ at a certain

time and at a certain place. People’s individual experiences are continuously

being recreated in that context. This context is the perceived (!) issue around

which people may interact. Hence the pieces of information will continuously

change. Therefore, reflecting the ideas of complex responsive processes of

relating in organisations, their gestures and responses will continuously

change.

This is another way of saying that each action people make, decisions they take,

information they create will change in each different circumstance.

Knowledge emerges in the gesture/response process as a social act.

Since these gestures and responses are the complex result of the many

individual’s past experiences and future expectations, so will the knowledge be

emerging out of those past experiences and future expectations in the context

of the perceived issue at hand.

Referring to paragraph 2 above, with continued interaction the expectations

and experiences will start to display complex themes or ‘patterns’.

Knowledge can thus be seen as a pattern that emerges out of these

interactions.

People’s actions are, in turn, governed by the emerging pattern thus closing the

loop. This loop helps us understand knowledge processes in organisations.

4 How organisations learn…

What we can learn from the paragraph 3 is that organisations don’t learn.

People as individuals learn.

Organisations are forums for people to interact. Organisations have been given

some form of intention by the people that work in/for them.

These people, though, are not isolated from the rest of their lives and context

outside of the organisation. If we mention a person’s individual past

experiences we mean all their individual experiences, in the business

organisation, at home, at their sports clubs, universities, on holiday, etc.

The processes of organising are these processes of interaction that we called

complex responsive processes of relating.

In the previous paragraph we described that ‘knowledge’ is one of the emerging

patterns in that process of organising.

But, at the same time, this patterning forms the process of interaction! Action

emerges out of the interactions whilst using the knowledge that emerges out of

that very action!

Cohen and Stewart (1997: 414-22) call such a relationship as here between

organising and knowledge a ‘complicit’ relationship.

Processes of organising Knowledge

ACTION EMERGES

Figure 3 – Action emerges, complicitly, out of organising and knowledge processes

Action emerges out of the coevolving relationship between knowledge and

organising. It is therefore inherently impossible to decouple knowledge from

the organising process. Since the entity of an organisation emerges out of this

complicit relationship, the complicit knowledge and organising processes are

‘the organisation’.

This has some major consequences for how we see organisational learning.

We can describe the learning in organisations as the continuous patterning that

is happening in the process of interactions.

Knowles (2002: 107-23) introduces the model of the Process EnneagramTM.

This model is a way to show the perspectives of the interactions as process

patterns. It does that via multiple (nine, ‘ennea’ (?????) is ‘nine’ in Greek)

unique perspectives.

In the interactions, people go through all perspectives all at the same time. This

is not a linear process at all. All nine elements are connected, but some

connections between elements will be stronger than others. That depends on

which people are interacting where and at what time. Thus, these patterns

reflect the collective histories of the interacting people, often organisations.

By paying attention to those connections we can see the patterns emerge.

People in organisations are thus given an insight in those patterns that they can

then internalise and use as pieces of information for their gestures and

responses.

Time

Patterns as shown in

Process Enneagram ©

People interacting via

continuous gesturing

and responding

Emergence

Figure 4 – Making emerging patterns visible

They will only ‘internalise’ those patterns if they see that these patterns

sufficiently resonate with their individual experience and intention. In other

words, the issue at hand (context) must be compelling enough for individuals

to want to engage in this way. Thus the interaction becomes the continuous

negotiation of what is and what is not compelling for individuals.

It is a very important leadership skill to be able to act (gesture) in ways that will

help people see the importance of the emerging theme. If the gesture is

compelling, people will respond to it in ways coherent with the leader’s

intention. The mentioned power relations may distort this view, because people

may act not because the issue is compelling, but because the potential

consequence of not acting the way a leader wants is compelling enough.

It is obvious that thus people do not internalise the emerging ‘knowledge’

pattern as part of their experience, but rather the ‘fear’ for repercussions. This

in turn becomes part of the organising pattern and hence organisational

‘action’!

It seems to me that this has significant implications for ‘organisational

learning’.

By internalising these emerging patterns as part of the interacting processes

this internalisation itself will become part of the patterns thus potentially

transforming the identity and intention of the interacting individuals.

Their individual transformation means they will act differently to the contextual

issues than they would have otherwise. Over time, we suggest that the

individual and collective identity and intention will converge since more and

more of the patterns will be internalised in each individual. They will never be

the same because each individual will still have an individual past experience

and future intention.

If the pattern that people make part of their individual identity and intention is

around the issue at hand than the action that people will take is important for

the organisation. People will have learned coherent action that will be ‘helpful’.

Applied to the issue this is knowledge creation in the definition above. Thus the

process of learning is the process of evolving new patterns.

If, on the other hand, people internalise the ‘fear’ pattern, than the individual

learning will be entirely different. There will be very little connection between

the issue and people’s actions and -hence- the knowledge pattern. Very little

has been learned. Evolution is not linked to real life issues, but rather to people

avoiding other people’s actions (the boss’s actions!). Our experience shows

clearly that this happens in organisations.

We already established that the process of organising and knowledge creating

are complicitly linked.

From the reasoning above we can see that organisational learning as emerging

patterns of knowledge happens when people chose to interact around issues

that are important to them as individuals. The process of organising, including

the importance of power relations, can help or work against this process.

Leaders, therefore, have the choice how to ‘gesture’ in organisations realising

that their gestures may carry more ‘weight’ than that of others.

Without leaders seeing the importance of truly involving their people by

appreciating that their gestures somehow will have to resonate with people’s

authentic experience, very little knowledge creation will happen.

We have to think about how certain ‘best practices’, defined as actions that

elsewhere have led to perceived positive (business) results, may or may not

resonate with people’s experience in the organisation where we work.

Actions, emerging from local interactions, are by definition local. ‘Best

Practices’ are therefore global patterns from specific local interactions. There is

little reason to see that they therefore will -automatically- resonate with other

people interacting locally.

In the words from above, practices need to evolve as patterns in organisations.

In the evolution metaphor, one can also not simply ‘plant’ a new species

somewhere and expect it to flourish.

Evolution of knowledge happens complicitly with the evolution of the

organising patterns. That is a major insight that surely must have major

implication on how organisations treat ‘managing knowledge’ and looking at

‘knowledge processes’.

5 A Story: ‘Sphinx’

We will now look at an example from all this in action. The particular story I will

use is about a business change management company I used to work for. Let’s

call the company Sphinx for the purpose of this paper. It is not the real name.

Knowledge as emerging patterns of interaction.doc © 2003, Symphoenix Ltd Page 12 of 15

Founders

‘Leadership team’

Sectors

Services

Knowledge Groups

Back-Office

Others

Figure 5 – Sphinx’s emergent structure (2000)

Sphinx has always been an organisation that relied on people organising

themselves in helping its clients through complex change programmes. In order

to do this, the creation of novel and creative ways to help the clients is of

paramount importance. It is clear that the success of Sphinx’s business is firmly

based on knowledge (in the definition of this paper) and creativity. The way

Sphinx was organised was truly an emergent effect of the interaction between

people. In Figure 5 this is depicted as a series of ‘cells’. Usually people were

part of 2-3 cells at least. Some cells were permanent, others much more

transient, depending on the nature of it.

The ‘Knowledge groups’ were groups of people coming together to share ideas

and learning in areas that the people found important. The emergent nature of

it was that knowledge was being created when needed as perceived by the

group.

This is very consistent with the model described above, where the ‘organising’

process and the ‘knowledge’ process happen ‘complicitly’. Effective action (i.e.

helping the client) emerged. And, interestingly, there was no-one steering this.

People’s deliverables with clients were placed on a ‘Knowledge Database’, in the

language of this paper containing Information and Data about work that people

had done. In the Knowledge groups (either the more permanent ones or the ad

hoc ones) people would then refer others to material on that database that

seemed to fit into the emerging theme. These other could then ‘contextualise’

(read: create knowledge of these themes) in their own client environment.

The way of working was very successful and the company achieved very large

organic growth percentages year on year. The latter was of course not just due

to the way knowledge processes worked, but it certainly played a pivotal role.

Building on its success, the company decided on some aggressive growth plans.

The growth plans unfortunately coincided with an unforeseen sharp down-turn

in the consulting market in 2001-2. The company’s ‘management team’

decided that more structure was needed and imposed (sic!) that structure based

on its views. This happens in many organisations because often ‘structure’ is

associated with ‘control’. In my experience this is a flawed concept where,

despite this flaw, many organisations are based on. It ignores the resonance

with people other than the managers.

One of the structural components that were introduced was that a ‘Sphinx Way’

was developed. This meant to be an Approach (certainly not a detailed

methodology) that all in Sphinx would use as part of their ‘knowledge’.

‘Knowledge Teams’ were instated (as opposed to: ‘encouraged to emerge’) to

cover the subsets of this Approach, enabling management to control were

money would be spent on.

This had as a consequence that the Knowledge database was ‘restructured’ to

reflect the new Approach and the new Knowledge Teams were set up to

populate and maintain the database and proliferate the knowledge. Although

there are apparent advantages in doing that (for instance: common language)

the richness of the emergent knowledge groups was lost. More importantly,

‘knowledge’ was now reified and thought to be ‘transferable’. This did not

resonate with people’s experience at all! The Knowledge Teams very much

became mechanical groups and the Sphinx Way a management tool for

budgeting purposes. The database was no longer a source for conversation but

something that needed to be ‘populated’. Much money was spent on people

doing just that: populate it.

In the mean time, other changes happened and the company has since been

shrinking significantly. This might well be worsened because the main asset,

conversations that created novelty and new knowledge, was unwittingly

inhibited.

6 Conclusion

We cannot segregate the creation of knowledge from the organising processes

that happen in organisations (as in the Sphinx story). A helpful way of looking

at those organising processes is the relatively new idea of complex responsive

processes of relating. Using principles from the complexity sciences we can see

that out of the many complex interactions of gesture and response, patterns

will emerge in a self-organised way.

These patterns are leadership themes, reconciled individual intentions, etc. The

patterns make that people in organisation can act in a meaningful way.

Knowledge as emerging patterns of interaction.doc © 2003, Symphoenix Ltd Page 14 of 15

If we define knowledge as integrated pieces of knowledge in the ‘right’ context,

we can clearly see that knowledge can only be created in context. Without an

appropriate shared view of the context in which individuals act, knowledge is

not a meaningful concept since it cannot lead to effective action.

There is an all important leadership task to be able to help people see the

issues at hand (context) in a way that is important enough for those people to

choose to engage in the process of organising and -hence- in the process of

knowledge creation.

If people see the context too differently, actions will be ‘incoherent’ and no

positive knowledge creation and hence coherent action can happen.

The ideas of ‘best practice’ proliferation as ways to share information and

‘manage’ knowledge, has the potential of working counter productive if the

context in which it is being applied varies significantly from the originating

context. Chances are that they will be quite different on a global level. In that

case the information does not resonate with people’s experience and no

positive action can emerge out of the organising processes. This may explain

the difficulty in proliferating best practices in large organisations.

The codification of information (via databases, memos, books, procedures, etc.)

surely is an important part of the knowledge processes in organisations. But

without the facilitation of open and honest interaction between individuals in

organisations and the presence of leadership skills to help people ‘see’ the

emerging patterns and shared context there is very little knowledge creation

happening.

Sadly, in many organisations the emphasis of knowledge processes is focused

on capturing information, rather at this all important element of open, honest

and direct interaction.

Our suggestion is that leaders use structured conversations, for instance as

proposed by Knowles (2002) by using the Process EnneagramTM. This model

allows people to ‘see’ the emerging patterns as well as provides with a coherent

forum (‘map’) for sharing context and learning.

(Frank Smits, © February 2003)

References

Adams, D. (1995). The Hitch Hikers Guide to the Galaxy: A Trilogy in Five Parts.

London: Random House.

Cohen, J. and Stewart, I. (1994). The Collapse of Chaos, London: Penguin Books.

Heylighen, F. (1997). Classic Publications on Complex, Evolving Systems: a

citation-based survey, Principia Cybernetica Web,

http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/EVOCOPUB.html

Hock, D. (1999). The Birth of the Chaordic Age, San Francisco, CA: Berrett-

Koehler Publishers

Kelly, S. and Allison, M.A. (1998). The Complexity Advantage, Boston, Mass:

McGraw Hill

Knowles, R.N. (2002). The Leadership Dance, Niagara Falls, NY: The Center for

Self-Organizing Leadership

Stacey, R. (2000). Complex Responsive Processes in Organisations, London:

Routledge.

Zimmerman, B., Lindberg, C. and Plsek, P. (1998), Edgeware, Irving, Tx.: VHA,

Inc.

www.vGuitarLessons.com In this lesson you will learn a realy cool strumming pattern which not many people do. It will make your playing sound much more interesting! Go for it! www.vGuitarLessons.com

Related Pattern Articles